‘Unprecedented’ $18mn fine reflects SEC desire to recalibrate penalties and make them an effective deterrent
August 14, 2024 (Preqin News) – Private equity firms must review documents across portfolio companies to ensure compliance with the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) rules on whistleblowing protections, Debevoise & Plimpton said in its 2024 Private Equity Midyear Outlook.
The law firm pointed to an $18mn civil penalty agreed with JP Morgan Securities at the beginning of the year. The SEC determined that the absence of explicit language expressly permitting clients to report information to the SEC without risk of legal action concerning breaching confidentiality agreements was a violation of Rule 21F-17(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
Debevoise & Plimpton noted the fine was issued despite ‘prompt remedial actions taken by JPMS with respect to the contractual provisions in question.’
The law firm said the size of the fine, nearly double the next largest penalty of $10mn, reflects SEC Director of Enforcement Gurbir Grewal’s efforts to ‘re-calibrate penalties to more effectively promote deterrence, and get away from the idea that penalties are just another business expense’ including at large institutions.
The ruling expands whistleblower protections from employees to include investors, meaning private equity firms and their – public or private – holding companies, will need to review documents across their businesses to make sure whistleblowing activities are not impeded by confidentiality restrictions.
At the same time, the US Supreme Court has overturned the ‘Chevron defense,’ a 40-year precedent that means courts were to defer to a federal agency’s interpretation of ambiguous federal statutes if their interpretation was reasonable. Now, after the Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo ruling, courts are to make an independent judgment on whether an agency’s actions are statutorily authorized.
At a firm level, this may give the private funds industry more space to push back on SEC rules, as the SEC will need to make its rules better able to withstand legal challenges. At the portfolio level, more lawsuits challenging actions from federal agencies because they are not authorized by the applicable statute may be expected.
However, the Debevoise & Plimpton report also highlights the challenges that companies could face, as judges without technical subject-matter knowledge may issue impractical or unworkable rulings, or companies that have invested significantly in compliance with regulations face the prospect of these regulations being challenged.
This comes on top of the strike down of the SEC’s Private Fund Adviser Rule, which was intended to give investors more protection and visibility into private funds, although the SEC still has until September 3, 2024, to appeal the ruling to the US Supreme Court. Fund managers will now not be required to provide annual financial statement audits, nor certain disclosures within the quarterly statements on fund advisor compensation, fees, expenses, and performance.
Meanwhile, in Europe, several EU regulations have come into effect in H1 2024, including the amendments to the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (AIFMD). The amendments, known as AIFMD II, include a regulatory framework for managing funds engaged in loan origination.
The opinions and facts included within the above do not constitute investment advice. Professional advice should be sought before making any investment or other decisions. Preqin providing the information in this content accepts no liability for any decisions taken in relation to the above.