The secondaries market is set for a growth spurt, with GP-led transactions driving increased activity

The secondaries market is set for a growth spurt, with GP-led transactions driving increased activity

Falling or depressed public markets can have a dramatic impact on capital flows in private equity. First, lower valuation multiples tend to slow the pace of exits. This is partly because corporate acquirers are less able to fund acquisitions with equity and IPO windows narrow or close, but also because private equity owners hold assets for longer to be able to exit when multiples have recovered. Second, lower valuations on public equities can lead to institutional investors climbing above their target private equity allocations, limiting their ability to make new fund commitments.

The secondaries market can plug some of this gap. It has seen spectacular growth over the past decade, with the amount of dry powder available for investment standing at a record $131bn at the end of 2021 – nearly five times higher than the $28bn at the end of 2011. Dry powder in September had fallen to $115bn, indicating that there has been a healthy flow of transactions so far this year. With Preqin currently tracking 122 secondaries funds in market seeking an aggregate $82bn, the amount of available dry powder is set to climb to a new record.

Within secondaries deals, the big change has been a shift from LP-led to GP-led transactions. GP-led transactions accounted for 43.28%, compared with just 1% in 2012 (Fig. 1). Even allowing for data collection challenges in what is a particularly opaque part of the alternatives market, the trend is clear. 

GP-led transactions – often referred to as liquidity solutions – take many forms, outlined in detail by law firm Baker McKenzie. They can be an effective mechanism that works for both GP and LP, and continued growth in this booming segment seems assured, but there are also pitfalls investors, fund managers, and members of the limited partner advisory committee (LPAC) need to avoid. 

Jeremy Foo, partner and co-founder of Singapore-based secondary fund of funds manager Foundation Private Equity explains why the market can absorb increased transactions volumes, while James Burdett, partner and head of the London Investment Funds Group at law firm Baker McKenzie, argues for a pragmatic, real-world approach to regulation.

Jeremy Foo, Partner and Co-Founder, Foundation Private Equity (Singapore)

Demand for GP-led solutions will grow strongly over the next few years. Dislocation caused by the war in Ukraine, weak public markets, and ongoing COVID-19 lockdowns in China are among the factors that will necessitate liquidity solutions. A lot of funds that purchased assets at high valuations over the past few years will find it difficult to create upside if they seek exits in an environment in which public market valuations have fallen by around 50% in some sectors.

Also, in a difficult primary fundraising environment, GPs will look to the secondary market to stimulate interest in their fundraises. Stapled primary transactions and RMB to USD fund restructurings are examples of some of the structures that GPs are using to help with primary capital raisings.

Market demand for GP-led solutions is more than sufficient to accommodate increased supply. A lot of recent deals have been sizable and have consisted of syndicates of secondary funds. As more and more secondary funds get raised to tackle this growing need, GP awareness and willingness to consider a GP-led liquidity solution will also increase, which will increase the quality of deal flow as more and more top quartile GPs proactively seek solutions.

James Burdett, Partner, Baker McKenzie (London)

There are inherent conflicts in continuation fund transactions and sponsors need a rigorous approach to managing them. A key focal point is getting comfort that the valuation of the underlying asset or assets is fair and at arm's length terms, particularly given that investors in the selling and continuation funds will not be the same. This is especially the case for members of the LPAC, who will likely be called upon to sign off on the conflicts associated with the transaction.

It has been common practice for the sponsor to obtain a fairness opinion from an independent, third-party valuer. The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has proposed reforms to private funds, including making fairness opinion obligatory for all continuation fund transactions. There has been some pushback on this. 

Fairness opinions are not the only solution and there are scenarios when they may be viewed as surplus to requirements. For example, a continuation fund transaction may closely follow an aborted strategic sale that could provide a robust, recent open market valuation. Alternatively, a valuation can be achieved through a sale of a minority stake in the underlying assets to a third party, which is then used to benchmark the price for the sale to the continuation fund.

Ultimately, it should be for the parties to the transaction to decide what works for them. In certain cases, it is not entirely clear what a fairness opinion will add to the transaction, other than additional costs for the fund – and therefore, the investors – to bear.

 
 
Commentary in this article is provided by experts from Preqin Expert Voices network. 
Preqin Expert Voices is a global network of alternative asset professionals with in-depth industry knowledge and valuable ideas to share. We invite senior leaders and highly experienced commentators from across the industry to share their opinions in our forum, including fund managers, investors, consultants, advisors, academics, and more.
Are you a senior executive or thought leader? Are you a regular industry speaker? Are you a frequent commentator in the press? If this sounds like you and you would like to become an Expert Voice, then please get in touch at expertvoices@preqin.com.