BVCA boss Michael Moore talks about how private equity and venture capital can contribute to the new UK government’s ambition for economic growth

[Q&A headshot] Michael Moore, BVCA

Michael Moore, CEO, BVCA


Michael Moore is Chief Executive of the British Private Equity & Venture Capital Association, which he’s led since 2019. The BVCA represents 600 organizations across the private capital ecosystem, including more than 250 fund managers, 100 institutional investors, and 200 professional services firms. 
 
He is a former chartered accountant in corporate finance, Liberal Democrat Member of Parliament, and Secretary of State for Scotland. 
 
Grant Murgatroyd, Head of Preqin News, and Shaun Beaney, Editor of  Preqin First Close, asked him about working with the UK’s new Labour government, economic growth, pensions investment, and tax policy on carried interest.


Shaun Beaney: Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s new Labour government has made economic growth its top priority. What role could private equity and VC play?

We are very encouraged by the focus of the new government on economic growth. We have been working very closely with all the political parties for some time to make sure they understand the hugely important role that private capital plays. We’re excited about the opportunities that are there and encouraged by the very quick restatement by the Chancellor [finance minister], Rachel Reeves, of her objectives. It’s clear in the way this has been shaped publicly as well as privately that economic growth and getting more capital into the UK’s productive economy are key parts of what she has in mind.


SB: One of the government's policies is the creation of a National Wealth Fund to ‘attract significant private capital’ for decarbonization and economic growth. How are you engaging with it?

Prior to the election, we highlighted the different key areas of the economy in our Manifesto for Growth and showed how private capital can really help to turbocharge that ambition. The National Wealth Fund idea has been very encouraging. It’s still early days, so we’re looking forward to seeing more about the design of the fund and about collaboration and integration of policy for the UK Infrastructure Bank and the British Business Bank. But we’re confident that there's a lot more to add than just those two really important institutions. The broader principle of crowding in private capital is one that the Chancellor has repeated.


Grant Murgatroyd: Are there any particular models that you admire or think we should be following?

Institutions have an important role to play and making sure they are fit for purpose, and developing the agenda is critical. The role of businesses can be to make that infrastructure user-friendly for other businesses, or to make use of it themselves to be more economically productive. That’s critical. The more joined up that is, the better.

But it’s not just about institutions. The broader piece is to get capital into the UK. Something between 75% and 90% of the capital deployed through private capital funds in the UK is raised internationally. You need to set out credibility on the macro fundamentals.  So, political and economic stability, and having a plan that looks like it's for a decent period of time, that's test number one.

The second test is having an investment environment in the UK that has world-class regulatory standards and encourages investor talent to be here. We've got competitive advantages because we’ve got the largest hub of private capital expertise anywhere in the world outside the US.

The third area is predictable policy frameworks that allow you to know that if you invest in a particular part of the economy, the policy and tax arrangements will be consistent through your holding period of that investment.


SB: On investment and innovation, the BVCA has called for a new industrial strategy and the new government has committed to one. What’s your interaction with that?

Again, these are early days. People are rightly focused on the policy frameworks and the tax frameworks. But quite a lot of it is about signaling. It’s about setting out a plan and returning to it. We’re very, very clear that consistency of framing and policy-making will be critical in giving people confidence to invest, whether it’s VC – where you’re looking at exciting new, early-stage areas of the economy like life sciences, fintech, deep tech – all the way through to the mature bits of the economy, which will need to keep upping their game to remain internationally competitive. Policy and tax have got to be credible and consistent. 


SB: The UK’s previous industrial strategy in 2017 had a very strong innovation theme. How would private equity and VC contribute?

There are two huge areas where we have no choice as a country. The energy transition is a no-brainer. Across the globe, we’re on that journey. The UK government has got some pretty big ambitions that critically involve infrastructure. Some of the firms that are part of our industry will have asset strategies that include developing the infrastructure.  

Making that infrastructure usable to others and making sure it’s designed in a way that can help businesses and communities thrive and develop is also crucial. That’s a sweet spot for us. It’s the application of that infrastructure, making it fit for purpose for the real economy, where we’ve got a lot to offer. Whether it’s developing the ideas and bringing them to market or making the best use of those that come to market, VC and private equity align beautifully with that space.

The other area that’s not an option is digital transformation. AI is obviously a big focus. But it’s much broader and deeper than that.

We’re not shy in talking about how innovative private capital is as an industry, and how we want to foster innovation in others. If we can get more capital deployed to the right places in the economy, then we can do a lot together with the government and businesses. Other areas, like life sciences and AI, are brilliant opportunities for the UK. And we are clearly international leaders in fields like renewable energy. 


SB: Chancellor Rachel Reeves has suggested that the UK’s 80-plus local government pension funds could be consolidated and directed toward ‘productive’ investment. What would that mean for private capital? 

Different local government pension funds across the UK have been excellent at locally focused investment, in taking a shared responsibility and opportunity by collecting pension contributions from people working in local government and then recycling that through local economic opportunities which create jobs and give them the returns. So, part of this is about making sure that works really, really well.  
 
There's also the consolidation piece. Behind it lies a perfectly simple proposition: by making local government pension funds larger, you will be able to ensure that they’ve got the bandwidth and the internal expertise to do quite specialist investing. You don't invest in private capital in the same way that you do in equities and bonds. There is understandably a different skill set, and it’s more labor-intensive.

We’d love best practice to be more widely shared, and we’d love more focus on all of this, but we need to be sure that the scale of what’s created still has the ability to invest in the local areas. There are some fabulous regionally focused, mid-market businesses. They're exactly the kind of businesses that can take on this kind of capital and invest it. 


GM: Is there any danger that public-sector schemes become too focused on fees, which means they can't invest in private equity?

Across all types of pensions, we need to be very focused on what the value is. That’s about changing the conversation from being a cost-focused to value-focused discussion – to maximize savers’ pots in DC, and reduce public-sector costs in the Local Government Pension Scheme and public-sector DB. We are of course looking at Australia and Canada and saying: ‘Right, what bits of their programs are analogous?’

Local government pension funds have historically built up good knowledge of private capital investment and the long-term benefits, so we hope the government’s plans to reform them ensure they can retain that institutional knowledge.  


SB: Labour’s election manifesto said ‘unfairness in the tax system’ meant private equity was the only industry where performance-related pay is subject to 28% capital gains tax instead of 45% income tax. What’s your view?

We’re in the middle of a call for evidence. What has been very important for us thus far is what Chancellor Rachel Reeves has said in public. During the general election campaign in June–July, in an interview with the Financial Times, she said that where there’s a capital commitment, then it can be clearly linked to a capital gains situation. Where it’s not, it’s a bonus or performance-related pay. When the Chancellor was in the US a few weeks ago, she said it's entirely reasonable that when people are committed to the fund themselves, it gets treated as capital gains.

The key here is understanding that our member firms are very committed partners throughout the journey of a fund. The returns are only generated when everything has been assessed at the end of the process, and only then do they get the reward if all the institutional investors have had their very high benchmarks achieved, net of fees. It’s a pretty high bar, a long-term process, and fund managers have to be very engaged all the way through.

That you also have a contribution of your own capital is something that does exist in parts of the market already. We understand exactly what the Chancellor has in her sights in terms of what she has previously referred to as bonuses. But we don’t believe that’s essentially how the industry operates.  
 
We expect to help inform the decisions that will come in the government’s Budget on October 30. The principles that the Chancellor’s basing them on are ones that we are very comfortable to work with.


SB: How does your perspective as a former MP and government minister influence how you work with politicians and policy-makers?

What we’re explicitly recognizing – perhaps more so than we’ve done in the past – is that unless policy-makers can see the public value we generate, why would they care about us having a license to operate? The industry has gone on a journey to say: ‘Right, we’re bigger. We will embrace the outside world more.’ We now do that.

We’re engaging with Members of Parliament and we’re trying to understand where they’re coming from as well. So that’s what I bring, I think. I get that we all start from different places, and it’s our job to create the bridge to help everybody understand us. It's not on MPs to understand us if we can’t explain ourselves.  


Grant Murgatroyd is Head of News at Preqin and Shaun Beaney is the Editor of Preqin First Close. You can read all our latest coverage and free reports here. It’s quick, easy, and free to subscribe to our newsletter here. 
 
Economics, politics, and innovation will be high on the agenda at the BVCA Summit in London on September 11–12, in which Preqin is participating.


The opinions and facts included within the above do not constitute investment advice. Professional advice should be sought before making any investment or other decisions. Preqin providing the information in this content accepts no liability for any decisions taken in relation to the above.